reflection on teamwork in healthcare

doi:10.1108/LHS-12-2017-0076, Schippers, M. C., Den Hartog, D. N., Koopman, P. L., and Van Knippenberg, D. (2008). This effort set out to accomplish two primary objectives, both of which hold implications for research and practice: 1) to develop a comprehensive, evidence-based framework for healthcare team effectiveness, and 2) to generate a practical assessment tool that aligns with the framework and use this tool to identify common teamwork challenges. The exemplar team for reflecting on progress was comprised of multi-disciplinary clinical professionals, including physicians and staff members, who were highly interdependent. Reflection allows you to identify and Family presence during resuscitation in a rural ED setting, My aching back: Relieving the pain of herniated disk, Nurses and smoking cessation: Get on the road to success, The nurse's quick guide to I.V. WebFront-line medical teams are experiencing unprecedented stressors as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic. Oostra (2016) describes how the dyad leadership structure has evolved from a rigid, largely separate dual reporting system to an interdependent, situationally distributed model with shared roles and responsibilities. Coordinating interdisciplinary care for patients in today's work environment can be challengingthis is where situational awareness comes in. Finally, we complement these two objectives by providing evidence-based strategies or solutions, drawing from both the literature and our collective experience with team development, for addressing these common challenges. Individually, people reflect on things and then bring their thoughts and ideas to a collective process of reflection. For each agenda item, specify the intent: 1) Update (to simply inform the team about progress of plans), 2) seek Input (to request others perspective or feedback), or 3) Decide (to make the decision or determine who will make the decision). Towards the accomplishment of Objective 1, a framework for team effectiveness, informed by team science and grounded in data from the field, is introduced and critical team competencies defined. 202, 99107. doi:10.1002/job.537, Stapleton, P., Henderson, A., Creedy, D. K., Cooke, M., Patterson, E., Alexander, H., et al. doi:10.1177/0021886306298892, Calhoun, J. G., Dollett, L., Sinioris, M. E., Wainio, J. Coaching has received considerable attention from the literature (Smither, 2011; Grant, and Hartley, 2013; Bozer, and Jones, 2018), and has been found to be instrumental to employee learning and development (Ladyshewsky, 2010; Liu and Batt, 2010; Jones et al., 2016). doi:10.1108/eb022847, DeChurch, L. A., Mesmer-Magnus, J. R., and Doty, D. (2013). 61 (11), 15931616. West, M. A. Team effectiveness and team coaching literature review. Change 13 (2), 95105. J. Small Group Res. Applied to decision making, Phillips (2002) asserts that one factor that may influence procedural justice is the perceived decision control, or level of influence the leader gives a team members input relative to others. As a starting point, research on the training needs of the dyadic pair and the development of a competency model (essentially, what makes a dyadic pair effective) could help inform leadership development programs. These tools can focus on personality, emotional intelligence, 360 feedback or a number of other critical performance areas. When you hand good people possibility, they do great things. Biz Stone 2. BMJ Qual. To encourage accountability, each member of the team was required to sign an individual accountability contract, holding them to a standard output of quality and quantity. J. Manag. Lencioni (2012) describes at one end of extreme teams can experience artificial harmony, where team members dont engage in open, constructive conflict (e.g., because of low levels of trust, desire to appear agreeable, discomfort with confrontation) and strive to keep a level of peace. Diversity, conflict, and team performances summary of program of research. While there are many practical resources for team coaching best practices (e.g., Thorton, 2010; Hawkins, 2017), more empirical research into overall effectiveness and the specific techniques that work best, the length of engagements, the impact of team types, and specific desired outcomes that are most amenable to coaching is needed. The authors tested and found support for their hypothesis with 98 multidisciplinary primary health care teams, including physicians, practice managers, nurses, and administrators. It's essential that all interdisciplinary team members are knowledgeable about each other's job role, responsibilities, and level of accountability at the unit and organizational level. Drawing from the literature on a similar group process (i.e., team debriefs), teaming coaching sessions may also be more effective when the development, non-punitive, and non-administrative intent is stressed, when teams reflect on specific events rather than general performance or competencies, and when multiple sources of information are used (e.g., multiple team members, objective data source). may email you for journal alerts and information, but is committed 45 (7), 28912919. Dow A, Thibault G. Interprofessional Education - A Foundation for a New Approach to Health Care. For this model to be effective, both leaders must draw from each others complementary strengths, be included in decision making, and present as a united front supporting and maintaining any decision made. Team-training in healthcare: a narrative synthesis of the literature. Rowe (2019a) defines leadership as striving to motivate and inspire staff to achieve shared goals. 2018;73(4):433-50. The Team Diagnostic Tool, designed to capture a snapshot of team effectiveness and reduce the survey fatigue common in healthcare, was developed in three steps: First, one subject matter expert (SME) drafted one survey item per competency in the framework. Dev. This is a situation where a developmental opportunity allowing them to improve inter-departmental dynamics as well as their collective efficacy was deprived as a result of lack of one-on-one meetings with leadership to address these concerns through coaching. CP f Nursing homes: 2: 2: Hence, prior to the implementation of coaching efforts, it is critical to ascertain this information (i.e., leadership buy-in and commitment). I will use knowledge that I gained from this experience in my everyday practice. Building competency in the novice allied health professional through peer coaching. Decisions on how policies and procedures (e.g., billing, covering shifts) should be carried out were often decided by one member of the leadership without involvement from the other dyad leader. Manag. FIGURE 1. (2008) argue team reflexivity may be especially beneficial under high levels of work demands (e.g., high patient-to-clinician ratio, time pressure). Psychol. Manag. 80 (2), 292316. Bowers, C. A., Braun, C. C., and Morgan, B. Every team member plays his or her particular role and takes on Importantly, both of these can be distinct from those who must agree or sign off on a decision before it can move forward. Leader. doi:10.1007/978-3-31933261-1_2. doi:10.1002/hrdq.1033, Thorn, P. M., and Raj, J. M. (2012). Care Res. Editors Brannick, M. T., Salas, E., and Prince, C., (Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates), 85108. AW contributed substantially to data analysis and manuscript development/writing. 4 (5), 396407. Manag. 96 (2), 391400. 13 (6), 417421. A multilevel approach to theory and research in organizations: contextual, temporal, and emergent processes. in Multilevel theory, research and methods in organizations: foundations, extensions, and new directions. Qualitative inquiry was used to provide rich detail about how each one of these challenges may manifest in the field and the impact of these challenges on team outcomes including performance, functioning, and viability. Brown, A., Dickinson, H., and Kelaher, M. (2018). Med. Research on individual vs. team decision making bears out that teams can outperform individual decision makers in terms of decision accuracy, and that process gains cannot be explained by the most knowledgeable member or even the average level of knowledge across the team (i.e., theres a synergistic gain; Michaelsen et al., 1989). In short, there was a lack of a shared mental model or clarity around what each group does and thinks (e.g., how long it takes to do certain tasks, the effect of changes to the patient plan) and awareness of how the situation impacts each group. (1997). Who has the d?. As dyadic pairs can take many forms (e.g., physician and registered nurse, physician and operations manager), uncovering the challenges specific to each of these team types would also move research forward. Thorn and Raj (2012) identify four core coaching behaviors: 1) be authentic, 2) ask powerful questions, 3) establish trust, and 4) challenge beliefs. 74 (5), 834839. Dierdorff, E. C., Fisher, D. M., and Rubin, R. S. (2019). The leader coach: a model of multi-style leadership. The WGEA, WGSA, and WOSR invite abstracts for workshops, small group discussions, oral abstract presentations, & posters for the 2023 collaborative conference. These participants included 10 healthcare leaders representing a variety of functional areas (including Nursing Education, Pharmacy, Communications, Interprofessional Education, Performance Improvement, and Leadership Development), three team science SMEs, and 13 frontline healthcare employees. Effects of after-event reviews on voice behaviour and hierarchy beliefs in multi-professional action teams. Effective healthcare teams require effective team members: defining teamwork competencies. Sanford, K. (2015). Workplace harmony hinges on community, she explained, and if the community is weak and colleagues are unsupportiveor engage in incivility and bullyingit is difficult to resolve conflict and the team suffers. B., and Helmreich, R. L. (2004). Working in effective teams improves clinical outcomes, increases professional satisfactionand provides crucial peer support. J. Manag. When patients are surveyed postdischarge, the department most often referenced for satisfying encounters is nursing. Relationships between accountability, job satisfaction, and trust. doi:10.1200/JOP.2014.003350, Taylor, P. J., Russ-Eft, D. F., and Chan, D. W. (2005). The development of this framework synthesized literature on teamwork competencies and overall team effectiveness across multiple disciplines within healthcare. Team members should be encouraged to ask questions, share ideas or concerns, and discuss potential solutions. This trait, however, does not serve us well in the modern context with our health care colleagues. Dietz AS, et al. 90 (1061), 149154. Broadly, these consisted of a general lack of one-on-one meetings with leadership and an absence of feedback on work-related activities and progress. What are your teams weaknesses? How do you build trust and support so that if something goes wrong, people dont hide it or fail to resolve it or get worried that theyll get in trouble, but instead actually work together to get it solved?. J. Posit. The purpose of these exercises would be to give team members an opportunity to share professional goals and aspirations with both the leader and the team. Decision consensus occurs when all members with responsibility for making the final decision agree. The department experienced a significant amount of turnover from both managers and frontline staff. The simultaneous need for and challenge to teamwork, though, is not unique to healthcare. Hence, institutional size could influence the present findings. Finally, the person(s) with the authority to decide makes the final decision, and those who perform carry out the decision. Specifically, given the scarcity of resources that often faces healthcare teams (e.g., time, financial resources), a team effectiveness measurement tool can guide efforts and maximize effects of any intervention. Teamwork is also essential to the success of an organisation and to the development of each employee. 46 (4), 685716. Survey participants were 96 healthcare professionals (N = 10 teams, 96 individuals; 66.7% F, 32.3% M) from a large healthcare organization in the Southwest United States employed across a variety of clinical and administrative functions. Factors 38 (2), 300310. Start, stop, continue tutorial. Individual thought is respected and invited; collective thought is encouraged and developed. Accountability is an enormous and sometimes complicated concept; teams presenting with a concern around accountability could be experiencing a number of underlying issues. 14(1), 6983. J. Oncol. Creating opportunities to observe others in their clinical settings is one method for achieving this perspective. While the importance of teamwork across all types of healthcare teams (e.g., administrative and research teams; Leggat, 2007) has been recognized, the majority of research is conducted with clinical teams. Teams, tribes and patient safety: overcoming barriers to effective teamwork in healthcare. For example, when team members have a different understanding of the intent of a decision making discussion, it can create problems for the team. A comparison of clinical and non-clinical teams revealed the top challenges remained largely the same across the different functions. As any nurse working in the NHS knows, teamwork can be powerful. Bus. An analysis of 84 root cause analysis-reports from Danish hospitals. 33 (1), 3264. Results: The five most common challenges that face healthcare teams relate to accountability, conflict management, decision-making, reflecting on progress, and coaching. Reflexivity has been evidenced to predict team effectiveness, creativity, and innovation (e.g., De Dreu, 2006; Tjosvold et al., 2003; Tjosvold et al., 2004). First-year medical students are broken into groups of four and five within their anatomy teams. 17 (4), 368392. 89 (2), 249277. doi:10.1037/0003-066X.45.2.120, Taplin, S. H., Weaver, S., Chollette, V., Marks, L. B., Jacobs, A., Schiff, G., et al. Its huge. Coaching can positively impact goal attainment, resilience, morale, and well-being (Stapleton et al., 2007; Grant et al., 2009). Adequacy of group decisions as a function of the decision-making process. At present, the field has yet to establish a robust, evidence-based multidisciplinary framework for effective teamwork that can be integrated into current medical education curriculum. Editor(s): Davis, Charlotte BSN, RN, CCRN. In teams where power or influence is distributed unequally, majority rule can have a potential for reducing these inequalities (Falk and Falk, 1981). WebThis teamwork was an intense exercise in learning the practical dynamics of working with people from different medical disciplines and backgrounds for me. Team roles: a review and integration. 4 What do you need to able to succeed as a member of this team? Taken together, these factors can lead to silence being interpreted as agreement when team members are avoidant of conflict. A theory of team coaching. Harv. This study received Institutional Review Board exemption and did not require informed consent (Protocol 2020-0627). This approach has the potential to change the way we interact with each other in clinical settings and ultimately transformthehealth careenvironment. Editor Koppes, L. L., (Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Publishers), 407438. (2010), an essential piece of team coaching is assisted reflection and analysis. Importantly, the dyad members do not report to or work for one another; rather, each has their own responsibilities and accountability for their joint work. A New Focus on Teamwork. Physicians have historically acted as the focal point around which all caregiving institutions focus. Team-oriented Goal Setting. Set the Bar. Learned Communication Skills. Encouraging Respect and Trust. Determining, Identifying and Assigning Specific Roles. J. Interprof. (2015). Exploring the qualities of a good leader using principal component analysis. doi:10.1080/17521880903559697, Bushe, G. R., and Coetzer, G. H. (2007). 9 (2), 142150. Being able to communicate and work collectively as a team requires an appreciation for each others area of practice. Specifically, we present a blueprint for fostering team effectiveness through a hierarchical structure of building blocks organized by overarching themes (i.e., levels). Teamwork requires more than just communication skills, coordination or even mutual goals. We introduce a comprehensive framework for team effectiveness. In this sense reflection deepens learning, it allows us to develop at a faster pace. A culture of coaching: achieving peak performance of individuals and teams in academic health centers. Does simulation-based medical education with deliberate practice yield better results than traditional clinical education? As the leaders grappled with their own accountability, the team was rarely consulted to provide input or recommendation. Importantly, patient outcomes are impacted by clinical, administrative, and research teams alike. Finally, the enabling conditions, or what the dyadic pair needs from the organization and environment in which they operate, can add to the overall picture of dyadic leadership team effectiveness. The final framework contains 27 competencies that are critical to team effectiveness in healthcare (see Figure 1 for framework and Appendix A for a description of competencies). Just as you begin to develop cohesion and get to know each other, you are off to a new group with a different set of personalities. He noted that it is up to attending, chief, and senior residents to set the tone. doi:10.1016/S1470-2045(06)70940-8. Below, we present five common teamwork challenges along with case studies that were derived from the qualitative data collection effort (i.e., from the interviews and focus groups conducted during the team development activities). 15 (2), 175184. To achieve our second objective, we created and administered a diagnostic tool aligned with the framework. (2002) found accountability measures increased employee perception that coworkers and managers were aware of their work, and ultimately improved job satisfaction.While the accountability document was intended to increase motivation and follow-through, it was perceived as a way to place blame and punish those who did not meet goals. J. Appl. Our framework addresses both of these concerns by defining components to team effectiveness that are essential to multidisciplinary teams across healthcare contexts (i.e., clinical, administrative, research). WebReflective Essay on Teamwork. Team effectiveness can remain elusive and ill-defined if not clearly operationalized and consistently measured. From causes to conditions in group research. 22617608). Acad. The people you work with are the people who can understand you the best and be the best source of support, but they also have the power to make your life miserable; what people refer to as a socially toxic workplace, Maslach said. BMJ Qual. Because of this uncertainty at the top level, participative decision making was also low and left members unheard or unappreciated. Hum. While the authors highlight the many potential benefits (e.g., automated steps, greater access to information when and where it is needed, decision support, integrated care plan), they also acknowledge potential drawbacks, including issues with communication (i.e., access to the technology, overloading members with messages). Better teamwork is associated with lower patient morbidity and mortality, as well as other critical outcomes such as reduced nursing turnover and increased patient satisfaction. How smoothly physicians make this transition often depends on the teams they have the fortune or misfortune of being part of, said Brenessa Lindeman, MD, MEHP, chief resident of the Department of General Surgery at Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine and member of the AAMC Board of Directors. (2004). Group Organ. Instead of clearly defining what fell into shared and individual responsibility (i.e., who held the Decision role in the RAPID model), the pair had loosely defined the PA leader as the final decision maker on administrative duties, and the physician leader on clinical duties. As previously mentioned, we aimed to achieve two objectives: 1) to develop a comprehensive, evidence-based framework for healthcare team effectiveness, and 2) create a practical assessment tool that aligns with the framework and use this tool to identify common teamwork challenges. Accountability, the department experienced a significant amount of turnover from both managers and frontline staff my everyday practice for... Improves clinical outcomes, increases professional satisfactionand provides crucial peer support Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Publishers! Informed consent ( Protocol 2020-0627 ) root cause analysis-reports from Danish hospitals ( 2018.... With leadership and an absence of feedback on work-related activities and progress the success of organisation. Approach has the potential to change the way we interact with each other in clinical settings ultimately. Share ideas or concerns, and trust result of the COVID-19 pandemic institutional! Mesmer-Magnus, J. M. ( 2012 ) and hierarchy beliefs in multi-professional action teams an and. Then bring their thoughts and ideas to a collective process of reflection, Sinioris, M. ( 2018.. From different medical disciplines and backgrounds for me and backgrounds for me Protocol 2020-0627 ), Bushe, R.. Of other critical performance areas environment can be challengingthis is where situational awareness comes in or concerns, and processes! Ask questions, share ideas or concerns, and Coetzer, G. (! Team requires an appreciation for each others area of practice defining teamwork competencies overall! 2020-0627 ) around which all caregiving institutions focus COVID-19 pandemic team-training in healthcare, discuss. Kelaher, M. E., Wainio, J on personality, emotional intelligence, 360 feedback a! Manuscript development/writing each employee in their clinical settings and ultimately transformthehealth careenvironment novice allied health professional through peer coaching situational. Dow a, Thibault G. Interprofessional education - a Foundation for a New approach reflection on teamwork in healthcare... Covid-19 pandemic analysis of 84 root cause analysis-reports from Danish hospitals will use knowledge that i from... Making was also low and left members unheard or unappreciated at the top remained... 'S work environment can be challengingthis is where situational awareness comes in or unappreciated as the grappled! In multi-professional action teams elusive and ill-defined if not clearly operationalized and measured! Teams, tribes and patient safety: overcoming barriers to effective teamwork in healthcare occurs when all members responsibility. Covid-19 pandemic making was also low and left members unheard or unappreciated medical and! Personality, emotional intelligence, 360 feedback or a number of other critical performance areas education - a Foundation a... Feedback on work-related activities and progress a general lack of one-on-one meetings with leadership and absence! A model of multi-style leadership than just communication skills, coordination or even mutual goals 360 feedback or number! He noted that it is up to attending, chief, and Raj, J. G., Dollett, L.. Physicians have historically acted as the focal point around which all caregiving institutions focus the focal point around all... In effective teams improves clinical outcomes, increases professional satisfactionand provides crucial peer support are broken into groups of and... Way we interact with each other in clinical settings and ultimately transformthehealth careenvironment was low! Of one-on-one meetings with leadership and an absence of feedback on work-related activities progress. Questions, share ideas or concerns, and New directions of coaching achieving... Members: defining teamwork competencies J. R., and senior residents to set the tone the...., chief, and New directions enormous and sometimes complicated concept ; teams presenting with a concern accountability. Consisted of a general lack of one-on-one meetings with leadership and an absence of feedback on work-related activities progress..., however, does not serve us well in the novice allied professional... Effective team members are avoidant of conflict and to the reflection on teamwork in healthcare of an organisation and to success. Members unheard or unappreciated comes in, CCRN an appreciation for each area! Silence being interpreted as agreement when team members should be encouraged to ask questions, share ideas or concerns and... S ): Davis, Charlotte BSN, RN, CCRN comes in,. With a concern around accountability could be experiencing a number of underlying issues tribes and patient safety overcoming! Together, these consisted of a good leader using principal component analysis program of.... Their own accountability, job satisfaction, and Chan, D. ( 2013 ) us to develop a. This trait, however, does not serve us well in the modern with. Ideas to a collective process of reflection and to the success of an organisation and to success. Nhs knows, teamwork can be powerful better results than traditional clinical education all caregiving focus. Organizations: foundations, extensions, and Rubin, R. S. ( 2019 ) defining teamwork competencies overall... Culture of coaching: achieving peak performance of individuals and teams in academic centers... Committed 45 ( 7 ), 28912919: achieving peak performance of individuals teams. Consisted of a good leader using principal component analysis for making the final decision agree comprised multi-disciplinary. Including physicians and staff members, who were highly interdependent should be encouraged to ask questions, ideas. Objective, we created and administered a diagnostic tool aligned with the framework conflict, and team summary! Consent ( Protocol 2020-0627 ) this experience in my everyday practice individual thought is encouraged and developed and methods organizations. D. ( 2013 ) for reflecting on progress was comprised of multi-disciplinary professionals. To silence being interpreted as agreement when team members are avoidant of conflict narrative. Thorn, P. M., and team performances summary of program of research meetings with leadership and absence! I will use knowledge that i gained from this experience in my everyday practice members unheard or unappreciated emergent.... And trust from this experience in my everyday practice, CCRN of conflict one method for achieving perspective... Critical performance areas individual thought is respected and invited ; collective thought is reflection on teamwork in healthcare and invited collective... Contextual, temporal, and Kelaher, M. ( 2012 ) who were highly interdependent second objective we. Left members unheard or unappreciated uncertainty at the top level, participative decision making was also low and left unheard. Different medical disciplines and backgrounds for me teams in academic health centers discuss potential solutions Helmreich. Context with our health care, Thibault G. Interprofessional education - a Foundation for a approach! Can focus on personality, emotional intelligence, 360 feedback or a number of other critical areas. Did not require informed consent ( Protocol 2020-0627 ) method for achieving this perspective and Chan, W.! In their clinical settings is one method for achieving this perspective invited ; collective thought is and..., patient outcomes are impacted by clinical, administrative, and Coetzer, G. H. ( 2007.... In organizations: foundations, extensions, and Rubin, R. L. ( 2004 ) email... And analysis deepens learning, it allows us to develop at a pace! ( 2012 ) ), 28912919 present findings P. J., Russ-Eft, W.. These factors can lead to silence being interpreted as agreement when team members are avoidant of conflict Davis, BSN! New directions when team members: defining teamwork competencies and Chan, D. F., and Raj J.. The leader coach: a model of multi-style leadership research and methods in organizations: contextual, temporal, Helmreich., increases professional satisfactionand provides crucial peer support may email you for journal alerts and information, but is 45. Leader coach: a narrative synthesis of the literature J. R., and,! Rubin, R. L. ( 2004 ) administrative, and emergent processes Publishers., ( Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Publishers ), 407438 teamwork.... The success of reflection on teamwork in healthcare organisation and to the success of an organisation and the... And staff members, who were highly interdependent this team of the literature essential piece of team is. Turnover from both managers and frontline staff doi:10.1200/jop.2014.003350, Taylor, P. M., discuss. A comparison of clinical and non-clinical teams revealed the top challenges remained largely the same across different. In multilevel theory, research and methods in organizations: contextual, temporal, and emergent processes provides crucial support! Multilevel theory, research and methods in organizations: foundations, extensions, and emergent processes W. ( ). These tools can focus on personality, emotional intelligence, 360 feedback or a of. Responsibility for making the final decision agree and teams in academic health centers awareness... But is committed 45 ( 7 ), 407438 set the tone Koppes, L., Sinioris, E.. D. ( 2013 ) members unheard or unappreciated require informed consent ( 2020-0627. Surveyed postdischarge, the department experienced a significant amount of turnover from both managers and frontline staff top,., administrative, and discuss potential solutions leadership as striving to motivate inspire... To communicate and work collectively as a member of this framework synthesized literature teamwork., Fisher, D. W. ( 2005 ) their anatomy teams with deliberate practice yield better results than traditional education! Outcomes are impacted by clinical, administrative, and New directions of four and five their. Frontline staff, Bushe, G. H. ( 2007 ) doi:10.1002/hrdq.1033, Thorn, P. J., Russ-Eft D.., C. A., Dickinson, H., and trust presenting with a concern around accountability could experiencing. Referenced for satisfying encounters is nursing when patients are surveyed postdischarge, the department a. Medical teams are experiencing unprecedented stressors as a member of this team complicated concept ; teams presenting a! Patients are surveyed postdischarge, the department experienced a significant amount of from! These factors can lead to silence being interpreted as agreement when team members are avoidant of conflict Davis, BSN... Operationalized and consistently measured point around which all caregiving institutions focus you hand good people possibility, they do things! Meetings with leadership and an absence of feedback on work-related activities and progress different functions the simultaneous for... To attending, chief, and discuss potential solutions and Helmreich, R. S. ( 2019....
Most Valuable Topps Baseball Cards 2021, 2027 Basketball Rankings Team, Riddle Funeral Home Obituaries Vermilion, Ohio, Reasons Why China Will Not Be The Next Superpower, Rebecca Herbst And Michael Saucedo, Articles R